Saturday, October 10, 2009

Evaluate. icon. Ver 2.0

I need your help. Yes, i need your help. Kindly reply all the question im going to ask and leave a comment. Before, lets take a look at my raster/pixel and vector that ive created. Ok, lets move on. 1st question.
1) Did they look like an icon?
a) Yes
b) No
c) what is an icon XD

2) Can you recognize what theme it represent?
a) Lion dance
b) Tiger
c) unknown animal/creature

3) Do they look nice for you?
a) Yup
b) Nope
c) Kinda

4) How was the color combination for the icon?
a) Awesome
b) good
c) can be improve

5) Can you see the home icon and contact icon clearly for both raster and vector?
* look at the smaller version icon*
a) Can
b) Can't
c) not really clear.


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


DETAILED VECTOR USER TESTING !!!

The Vector contact icon. ( below )




The Vector home icon. ( below )

This is a image to criticize for vector icons~

Ok lets start.

6) Which one you prefer for the home and contact icon?
( answer it from home to contact. etc: 1,1 , 3,2 , 2,4 )

7) Which 2 icon doesnt really show the message- home and icon ?
( answer it from home to contact. etc: 1,1 , 3,2 , 2,4 )

8) How was the design?
a) Well done.
b) Good.
c) Can be improved.

9) What can be improve?
( write your own opinion )

10) Which color combination looks nice?
( answer it from home to contact. etc: 1,1 , 3,2 , 2,4 )


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


DETAILED PIXEL USER TESTING !!!

This is a image to criticize for on my pixel/raster icons~
p/s this image color wasn't really accurate

Ok lets start.

11) Which one you prefer for the home and contact icon?
( answer it from home to contact. etc: 1,1 , 3,2 , 2,4 )

12) Which 2 icon doesnt really show the message- home and icon ?
( answer it from home to contact. etc: 1,1 , 3,2 , 2,4 )

13) How was the design?
a) Well done.
b) Good.
c) Can be improved.

14) What can be improve?
( write your own opinion )

15) How was the color combination?
a) Well done.
b) Good.
c) Can be improved.

Kindly wrote down your name after you comment because i owe you a thank you.



JUST COPY the question 1 to 5 and paste it.
JUST add an '=' sign below each question and write down your answer.
and finally add your NAME below it so i had a chance to thank YOU.
* I will post an example at the comment list *

17 comments:

  1. 1) Which one you prefer for the home and contact icon?
    1,4

    2) Which 2 icon doesnt really show the message- home and icon ?
    2,5

    3) How was the design?
    b

    4) What can be improve?
    The color, the design, the neatness

    5) Which color combination looks nice?
    1,1

    ~REDMOND~

    example

    ReplyDelete
  2. 1) 2,5
    2) 4,5
    3) good but can be more improved...
    4) i like the home icon, but both icon din really show the msg not clearly...maybe can make more strong the to bring out the contact n home feel...haha...anyway, i like u colour experiment...nice!!

    ReplyDelete
  3. 1) Which one you prefer for the home and contact icon?
    1(home),3(contact)

    2) Which 2 icon doesnt really show the message- home and icon ?
    1 for the contact and 2 for the home

    3) How was the design?
    c) Can be improved.

    4) What can be improve?
    Some of the icon have too many color and make it too complicated.can improved it making it easy to notice

    5) Which color combination looks nice?
    white n purple

    ReplyDelete
  4. 1) Which one you prefer for the home and contact icon?
    1,4
    2) Which 2 icon doesnt really show the message- home and icon ?
    2,1

    3) How was the design?
    b) Good.


    4) What can be improve?
    i think tat the design is good and simple enough,just the colour combination can be improved.

    5) Which color combination looks nice?
    1,4

    ~Tan Kok Loon~

    ReplyDelete
  5. 1b, 2a ,3c ,4b ,5a ,6(1,5), 7 (2,3) ,8C, 9 background can improve, 10 not sure, 11(3,2), 12(1,1), 13 C, 14 well no need all like tiger look can be other type cutie icon maybe. 15 C

    ReplyDelete
  6. 1b 2a 3c 4b 5b
    basically i dun think i suits as an icon le...
    too complicated...nt sophisticated enuf...
    kakaka~

    ~lai~

    ReplyDelete
  7. 1) Which one you prefer for the home and contact icon?
    c) what is an icon XD


    2) Can you recognize what theme it represent
    b) Tiger

    3) Do they look nice for you?
    a)Yup

    4) How was the color combination for the icon?
    a) Awesome

    5) Can you see the home icon and contact icon clearly for both raster and vector?
    * look at the smaller version icon*
    c) not really clear.

    ReplyDelete
  8. WTF you more question...
    1) yes
    2)Tiger dance? lol [ yea lion dance]
    3)yup
    4)good can be improve
    5}can
    6)1,5
    7)3,4
    8)good can be improve
    9)no idea yet
    10)1,5
    11)2,3
    12)4,1
    13)d, i like it...nice =)
    14)make it simple abit
    15)nice

    Liau Han Jie

    ReplyDelete
  9. 1(b), 2(a), 3(c), 4(c) bcos of de white 1.it looks like some kind of squirrel!!xD
    5(a), 6(1,1), 7(1,6), 8(b), 9 i donno much bout designing n colour coordination.but de colour is too complicated.mayb some lighter colour?? 10(4,1), 11(4,2), 12(no idea), 13(c), 14(no comment), 15(c)

    ReplyDelete
  10. 1)yes la for sure =.=
    2)b gua..
    3)c~~
    4)c
    5)c~for vector..if look at small
    6)apa lu cakap??=.=(4,2)
    7)(1,4)
    8)c
    9)the details of ur main msg, like the contact for vector rite is not obvious mayb because of the highlight and the head..can b improve~
    10)(4,4)
    =.= write wrong word...not vector is contact!!
    11)(2,3)
    12)(3 =.= veli obvious,2)
    13)b
    14)the pixel rite, both the main msg meaning the symbol of phone and home can be bigger?
    15)well done...(half boil egg XD)

    spam spam spam spam spam~~~~~~

    ReplyDelete
  11. good try in colour...overall is ok...not very special~

    ReplyDelete
  12. redant here~

    1. a
    2. a (but look like tiger leh..)
    3. c (i like both the pixel icon..nice colour combintation..)
    4. b
    5. a
    6. 4,3
    7. 3,4
    8. b
    9.
    10. 4, 1
    11. 1,1
    12. 2,2
    13. a
    14. 2nd home icon, the mouth(home) can be bigger..too small edi..
    15. a

    do so many...well done! lol

    ReplyDelete
  13. 1. a
    2. a
    3. a
    4. a
    5. a
    6. 4,3
    7. 3,4
    8. b
    9.
    10. 4, 1
    11. 1,1
    12. 2,2
    13. a
    14. The color can be improved
    15. a

    ReplyDelete
  14. Walao..so many question. =.=
    1) Did they look like an icon?
    a) Yes

    2) Can you recognize what theme it represent?
    *pixel look like Tiger.Vector is lion dance.

    3) Do they look nice for you?
    a) Yup

    4) How was the color combination for the icon?
    a) Awesome for vector. pixel............good..

    5) Can you see the home icon and contact icon clearly for both raster and vector?
    * look at the smaller version icon*
    a) Can for Vector!
    b) Can't really for Pixel..

    6) Which one you prefer for the home and contact icon?
    3 for contact ( maybe the colour of contact can change)....1&4 for home.

    7) Which 2 icon doesnt really show the message- home and icon ?
    3.5.2

    8) How was the design?
    a) Well done.

    9) What can be improve?
    the inner message that u wanna convey to audience. contact & home..dont really get it at 1st sight..

    10) Which color combination looks nice?
    4,1/5

    11) Which one you prefer for the home and contact icon?
    1,4

    12) Which 2 icon doesnt really show the message- home and icon ?
    3,2 (3 show a home but doesnt relate to ur theme?)

    13) How was the design?
    b) Good.

    14) What can be improve?
    The contact maybe can change to more obvious colour ? RED ? so tat from faraway can be seen easily is a contact..

    15) How was the color combination?
    a) Well done.

    Chien2. =)
    Nice Try in different colours!!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Dun ask me who i am... i am your best kawan...hehehehehe,

    ~ICON VER2:
    1)yes
    2)lion dance
    3)yup
    4)good
    5)can, clear enuf

    ~Detailed vector
    6)3,4...(the contact can make the colour similiar to the home icon that i prefer...)
    7)2,2
    8)gOOD!!
    9)erm... the contact icon... can be better i think...
    10)3,4

    ~Detailed Pixel
    11)1,4
    12)2,2
    13)WELL DONE, man~~~
    14)erm...same as the vector... contact one can b better...
    15)I luv the colour combination...

    ReplyDelete
  16. 1)a
    2)a
    3)c
    4)a
    5)*same as chien*
    6)4/6
    7)2
    8)a
    9)colour?
    10)4
    11~15. i cant comment coz i cant load the image. so sorry!

    ReplyDelete
  17. 1 yes
    2 a
    3 a
    4 c
    5 c
    6 2 3
    7 3 and none
    8 b
    9 i actually dont know >.<
    10 4 3
    11 3 2
    12 2 3
    13 b
    14 again i dont know >.<
    15 b

    ReplyDelete